!
+ : , % 5 & " ( # % " ( 6 - ( " - % - % 0 7 6 % 5 " $ ,
$&&846%6*-.$"%$2"!)+$5%
MBA
-!%,3&4-5$!%$&0!"!.12$%6/(!$"%$)"#5$5%$8!"8%-%9!&.12$5%3&(/6%$47(/%6"47%&./
&.8%91!%3&*!.&1%&(+*7!%3&&4!')5%64%&7617%3&(5/5%$/51%&65*(+%3!&$%-4%.$)"#57%"0*%6(7#%&./%2000%6.85%."!$&.!
9!1&67%78#5$%&4-5"%6&.1!6$%6-4!%("!&1%6.$15%&./%3!&1%.9!&.127%$15*$%&-!5&"%9)&-%6&.0*1%&6.$&1%2006-8%3&.87%.3&(+*
.;!.&#$%-(85%3425
6!"&4+%34%-#&%&5-)/%()#5%7!"&8%-%6&()&4$%&65!(6%.$.1!6%6*-.$!%78#5$%&4-5%6/(!$%-%3!&1%&"8%&()&4$%)!*&4$
.6&"/(8&$%)2-&&$$%6&&846%34%$"!4+%,!6&8%;!6%,$&5-)/7!%9!1&67%$.1!6%6*-.$!%78#5$%&4-5%6/(!$"%(8)$7%6&(!7&'
. ) 0 6 - / ( # $ " 4 % & ) " ( # % " " 8 % - % ( " $ 1 $ ) % 5 & . ) " ( . 3 ( 8
62&*(7&.!/7%&6-5"%,78#5$%&4-5!%$)&25657%,(2002)%&.8$%(/!6$%6/!%(1995)%9!8/($%(/!6$%6/%.<(/7%&.&58%(!-%&./
.$)"#57%2008-7%&65&&*%2(!2)!-$%6/%.$+&#
6&"&'0/%$&#.$%6&&0!"!-!65%$#6!+%()#5$%6(0*57%.78#5$%&4-5%6/(!$7%)2-&&$$%6&&8465%4-&%3!8&&7%)*!4%&"8%()#5$
.9!1&67%$.1!6%&2)&!(+%#!6&+%6&&#.$"%6!.!()4%$(&-05$%,
(Agile
)
.2(+7%9!1&67%$.1!6%&2)&!(+%6&&#.$"!%,""17%3&2)&!(+%6&&#.$7%)*!4$%4-&$%,!0"%$5!(6%-%&"8%()#5$%6!7&8#
0 . % & 0 . % " ( 6 - ( " - % - % 0 7 6 % 5 " $ ,
†!
6&7"%3&-!5&"%6&.1!6%#!6&+7!%,472$%6.0$"%$(7#7!%;!.&#$%-(857%6!&66&1%<!#%6!7&7*7%3&4-5$%6/(!$7%&6)*4%(747
.&67&7*%;!.&#7%6-)!55$%,(+*$
9!&.127%&6&84%2(!2)!-$%6/%.(!7(/%9/%,90&8&5%62*(7&.!/7%2(!2)!--2*!+%./"6%62&*(7&.!/5%-%$&0!"!&77%,&.8!%9!8/(%(/!6
$15*$%&-!5&"%9)&-%6&.0*%&./%3!&1!%,$)"#5$%"0*"%&6+(2'$%2000%6.87%.$7&7*%6!1&/!%$&&846"%;!.&#%3!#67%,(1998)
.9!&.127
6!&2.-!2*$!%&./%.&67&7*$%;!.&#$%"8%&+!*!"&+-&6(7#-&80($%2)+*/7!%(+*$%6&7"%<!#5%3&4-5%6/(!$7%6)*!4%&./%""11
.4-5"%3&.!8%3&.!/&:!5!%3&.0$!%472$%6!8(!%472$%6.0$"%$(7#$%34%$"!4+%,!6&8%6!5&&)5%&"8
,&67618%(+*%.6&"5(!+$%;!.&#$%61(457%30%,&67&7*$%;!.&#$%3!#67%()#5%6"&$)%6(&'&7%/&$%&"8%6&()&4$%$5!(6$
.$7&7*$%6.0$"%-(85$%6/'!$7%/'&%,3&1.#5"%-4!&5$
7 " ( 4 % & 0 " ( # % - % 5 & . ) " ( . 3 ( 8
6&(!2*$%$&+(0!/&07%6!#56$%-%9!8/(%(/!6"%&65"68$!%,472$%6.0$"%$(7#7%$1&(-51!%&.+!0%;!.&#"%$(!51%(747%&6-74
.2(!2)!-"%(&8&%"!"*57%6/'5.%&./%,9&&+%60"5!%2(&!!2!0%*(+%,,"!!%&*(+%&.8%34%,3!&1%%.&#%"6%6""157%-
.$:%(8)$7%3&.0$!%472$%6!8(%6!"&4+7%6!-)56$%;!6%,4727%$-&5"$%"8%$&.&&+/5%6/%(&7*5$%"-!5%6#6+5%&./%()#57
!
! & $ ( " : 0 % + $ ( # " % ( 6 ( . & " 4 # ) % " ( 6 - ( " - % - % 0 7 6 % " $ ,
3&4-5$%6/(!$7%(!2)!-%(/!6%&6"7&)%1974%6.87%.(1961-1954)%3&"8!(&7%6&(74$%$2&*(7&.!/$%"8%&.8!%9!8/(%(/!6%(0!7
3&)(+%,3&(5/5%122%&65*(+%3&.8$%;"$57%.$)"#5$%8/(%&6&&$%2000-1997%3&.87%.**)2%,9&2*!/%62&*(7&.!/7%($&0!"!&7)
;&(45!%,&4-5%;!.&#7%3&.!6&4%6!1(457%(7#%&./%.""!#7%6!.5:!5%6!/'($%25-!%3&*.17%3&()#5%135%&60'$!%-!5&"%&(+*!
&6(81$!%3&2.(!2)!-%14-!%3&2.(2*5%35%&6&#.$%."/(8&!%$&"(2*!/%,$&"0./%,7"$(/7%()#5%6!4'$!%2(!2)!-%,;5*!5%6!-!74
.$&0!"!&7"%3&(!5%6!/5
6&.-&#&%,678#!55%$7&7*7%()#%6!2&87%$&0!"!&7%3&-5!"$%3&-&5"6%"8%3&&7&2)+/!%3&&7&2&.0!)%3&08$%:&"8%()#5$%3!#6
High School Biology Curricula Development: Implementation,
%)(+$%67&61%:$.!(#/$%6&()&4$%&65!(6%.6!'!7)7!
Teaching, and Evaluation from the Twentieth to the Twenty-First Century
.
Handbook of Research in Science Education
%(+*7
0 & 0 , % 8 ( 4 , 4 % " " 8 % - % ( " $ 1 $ ) % . ) " ( . 3 ( 8
3&&#"%$50!-%$!!$5$%9+!/7%,3&-!$&!%3&7(4%3&'(5%3&-5"5%$78%,9&.1*7%3&(!5%6(81$"%6&5-)/$%$""15$%8/(7%-5!4%&./
.3&+6!85%3&&5-)/
$7&7*%&+"1%6!-54!%3&&5-)/%3&08&$%:3&&.&7$%67&2#"%'3&5:&.0(!/!()&5'%-!5&"%6-&#&%61(4$!%3!8&%,#!6&+"%,&"8%2(!2)!-$
3&2)+*/7%30%40!.%$:%()#5%.3&(:05$%&.87%3&&.&7$%67&2#7%-5".%-%6&(747!%6&7(47%-%$:%(+*%.(+*"%7*!$%,"3!"8!
.<(/7%3&+6!85$%!.&&#"%3&(!8)$%3&/8!.7%30!%3&&5-)/$
47...,12,13,14,15,16,17,18,19,20,21 2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,...1